Skip to main content

Buddhism and the Bilateral Brain: A Brief Sketch of Ideas Ranging from the Ancient Greeks, Early Buddhism, Nietzsche and a Smattering of Neuroscience

In Greek mythology, Apollo was the god of the reason and logic, appealing to the ideals of precision and abstract purity. Dionysus was the god of the spontaneous, the emotional, embodied, often irrational instinct. These gods were not considered to be antagonistic but rather complimentary.
Today, from the vantage of contemporary neuropsychology, especially in the works of Iain McGilchrist, Allan Schore and Robert Ornstein, we can readily note how these twin gods neatly represented the asymmetrical brain:
• Apollo depicts the perspective of the left hemisphere, which represents the world in static ideas; reality is comprised of separate and fragmented objects, abstracted from their context; reality is separated into parts. The kind of attention is inherently dualistic and isolating—self versus other, me versus you, humankind versus nature; this attention tends to represent the fluid and organic as lifeless, static, in language or symbols.
Dionysus depicts the worldview of the right hemisphere, which is complex beyond the capability of the rational mind to comprehend, fully embodied, ever changing, an interdependent, fluid, overlapping whole to which we are intrinsically connected.
As Iain McGilchrist notes, the Apollonian rational, left hemispheric attention "isolates, fixes and makes each thing explicit by bringing it under the spotlight of attention. In doing so it renders things inert, mechanical, lifeless. But it also enables us for the first time to know, and consequently to learn and to make things. This gives us power."
McGilchrist profoundly continues: "
Science has to prioritise clarity; detached, narrowly focussed attention; the knowledge of things as built up from parts; sequential analytic logic as the path to knowledge; and the prioritising of detail over the bigger picture… it comes at the world from the left hemisphere's point of view."
Ironically, while our contemporary culture idealizes the left hemispheric perspective, the right hemisphere is far more realistic in its depiction of how we live relation to the world; we are not separate, but connected. Yet the left hemisphere, which constantly views "I" and "me" as separate, unique and static, is wildly optimistic, believing it can solve everything, overcome death by 'not thinking about it,' avoid pain by 'figuring everything out;' the rational mind is, in short, utterly unrealistic about its limitations.
Nietzsche, in his book The Birth of Tragedy (1872) proposed that the goal of human existence was to achieve a fusion of Dionysian and Apollonian, the rational and the intuitive, via the arts. Certainly, the sublime experiences of one's favorite music requires both intellectual and emotional investment. For 
Nietzsche this fusion was made incarnate by the music of Richard Wagner (which I can personally take or leave but many find sublime).

From an early Buddhist perspective, the left-hemispheric brain (represented in the canon as the manas or dhammas, essentially the 'interpretive mind') creates what's referred to as 'sense consciousness" (vinnana), focused spotlight attention that fixates on objects and isolates them from the whole (a process called tammayata). This dominant form of attention is what activates the flood of self-conscious ideas (papanca), separating experience into those unceasing dualistic oppositions (light/dark, good/bad, useful/needless, me/you, and on and on). Yet without the left hemisphere, though, we would have no dharma, which represents spiritual practice in words and concepts; the left allows us to have 'yoniso manasikara,' or the possibility of cutting through appearances to observe core 'so called noble' truths.
The right-hemisphere (citta, or 'heart mind') meanwhile, provides us with an intuitive, connected, somatic and intuitive perspective. On the positive side, this provides us with the practices of kindness, compassion, appreciation and equanimity (the last of which requires some degree of reasoning as well). This is the realm of implicit memory, along with emotional states—when we're aroused, repelled, anxious, calm and on; prioritizes our relational lived experience over abstraction. Yet the right hemisphere has its shortcomings: in the form of unwholesome mental factors (akusalasādhāraṇa), we experience a irrational disregard for the consequences of our actions (Anottappa), restless anxiety, Uddhacca, stinginess (Macchariya), laziness (Thīna), uninspired defeatism (Middha) and fear (bhaya).
When both left and right hemisphere work in tandem, utilizing temperoparietal and cingulate regions of both hemispheres, 'mindful spacious awareness' is produced (sati, sampujhanna or atammayata), a greater awareness which doesn't abandon the irreducible totality of present moment (tathata); atammayata doesn't collapse around specific objects but stays open, fluid, available to attend to whatever arises without needing to collpase experience into lifeless ideas; and yet ideas are available when experience crystalizes into profound insights: everything is fluid and impermanent, altruism and pro-tribal acts form the foundation for lasting piece of mind.
To summarize these ideas sketched above: In tandem with the ancient Greeks,
Nietzsche and the Buddha, the goal is not to prioritize one perspective over the other, ie reifying the conceptual and interpretive over the embodied and intuitive, but rather to seek a fusion of the both worldviews, where the intellect and the intuitive could function in harmony, like Apollo and Dionysus.

jk 6/6/17


Popular posts from this blog

Is There Life on Earth?

Our ancestors knew that physical proximity, being seen in the eye of others via direct, face-to-face contact was, and is, the core foundation of mental and physical health. Without the emotional co-regulation that community provides, our sympathetic nervous systems never switch off, we’re forever on guard. 
Remember: The human species survived and thrived because we lived in tribes where individuals labored not just for themselves, but the benefit of others; we didn't survive by outrunning predators, for we are without wings, shells or claws; we survive because we are pack animals, wired to connect, our primary means to survive threats and heal our wounds; without connection chronic stress is the inevitable result.
     Loneliness is not a spiritual state to seek, it’s a health risk: the bonds of community, emotional mirroring, acceptance heal our wounds, help us grow, produce states of ease and confidence. People in communities live significantly longer, healthier lives.

5 ways to resist obsessive thoughts (Vitakkasanthana)

The mind can be thought of as a committee
Our thoughts are present by many "voices," some skillful and unskillful
W there are some skillful voices in there, focusing on useful ideas, there are also the many voices in the "committee" that cause us suffering by advancing and encouraging useless, stress inducing ideas, plans, worries.

Some examples of unskillful, stress producing obsessions
—are dedictated to figuring out the worst possible outcomes (fear) of any situation
—fixate on unknowable future events, i.e. what will we experience later in life?
—try to figure out what other people are thinking about us
—compare ourselves with others, especially in material concerns
in general, the buddha broke these down the thoughts of craving, aversion and delusion.

How unskillful internal voices persuade us
some of these committee members try to get their way by
—most work by repeating the same thought over and over
—some split into thousands of variations that seem different, but are …